Can AI be used to recommend Trinity Rock & Pop exam own choice songs?

Can AI be used to recommend Trinity Rock & Pop exam own choice songs?

Picture of Natalie Christopher

BY: Natalie Christopher
18 November 2026

Artificial intelligence (AI) tools are increasingly being used to support learning and exam preparation, including finding possible repertoire. But can they reliably recommend an own-choice song for a Trinity Rock & Pop exam? We tested ChatGPT to see what it suggested, how well those suggestions matched the syllabus parameters and where teacher and candidate judgement was still essential.

What are the requirements for selecting songs for a Trinity Rock & Pop exam?

Candidates taking a Trinity Rock & Pop exam must perform three songs:

  • Song 1 must be chosen from the Trinity Rock & Pop set list for that instrument and grade, performed with the backing track provided.

  • Song 2 can be another chosen from the Trinity Rock & Pop set list, or it can be a song of the candidates own choosing or composition. Own choice songs can be performed with live accompaniment, backing track or unaccompanied, but it must be of the same technical and musical difficulty as those songs chosen from the set list. It is therefore vital to refer to the parameters provided in the syllabuses when selecting an own choice song.

  • Song 3 must be chosen from the Trinity Rock & Pop set list but be one of those marked as a Technical Focus song. As before, it must also be performed with the accompanying backing track.

Song books (in digital and printed formats) and eBook singles are available to purchase from the Trinity Rock & Pop website.

What does AI base its suggestions on?

Having used ChatGPT in this particular exercise, it may be that other AI models differ in the information they can access and how they work. When asked, ChatGPT confirmed that it was mainly basing its suggestions on recordings and not written notation.

Even this explanation should be treated with caution as an AI tool may not be able to identify or verify the exact source behind a recommendation. This is not necessarily an issue for Trinity Rock & Pop exams, where the notation provided for the examiner can be published or transcribed as a score, TAB, or lead sheet with lyrics and chords. However, it is important to identify the specific recording being considered and ensure that the exam performance closely resembles it in musical and technical difficulty. If you intend to follow a published score, make additional checks to confirm that the score and recording align.

The parameters must come first

AI is clever but we’re not at a point yet when we can assume that by telling it you’re looking for an own choice song for a Grade 3 Drums or Grade 7 Bass exam, it will know exactly what all the requirements are.

For this example, we have opted for a Grade 5 Vocals exam. We started off by inputting the below prompt, followed by copying and pasting the parameters for this grade, found on pages 40 and 56 of the syllabus:

I want to choose an own choice song for a Trinity Rock & Pop Grade 5 Vocals exam. These are the parameters:

GRADE 5

Duration: 2.5–4 minutes

Time signatures: Irregular time signatures, more frequent changes of time signature

Range and register: Up to a 12th

Melodic writing and intervals: Increased chromaticism, use of pentatonic and blues scales

Other directions/techniques: Melisma

Improvisation: Improvised solos of about eight bars

Accompaniment: Moderately supportive backing

Interestingly, in its response, ChatGPT was able to include some of the guidance provided in the syllabus; for example, that not all of the parameters need to be included in that one song, and that the song can be transposed to suit the candidate’s range. But again, it’s important to always check this information against what is written in the syllabus and correct it, if necessary.

Related to this, it should also be noted that the parameters are cumulative. This means that, while it is not a requirement to find a song that contains all of the musical features listed for that grade, it is worthwhile checking that these demands do not dip below those for the one below. For example, while the Range and register parameter at Grade 5 says ‘up to a 12th’, at Grade 4 the requirement is ‘Up to an 11th; moving between high and low registers more common, including fast changes’. This should therefore be the minimum requirement for any song chosen at this level

Narrowing down the options

In its first response, ChatGPT provided an initial list of possible songs; however, it requested further information to be able to suggest more bespoke song recommendations. So, here is where we started tailoring it more to my personal preferences. We inputted:

  • a range of vocal influences including Amy Winehouse, RAYE, Olivia Dean, Ella Fitzgerald, but also stated that I liked a number of rock and indie artists such as Queen, The Killers, Muse and Florence + The Machine
  • my vocal range.

My top 5 song recommendations came out as follows:

  • Valerie by Amy Winehouse
  • Escapism by RAYE
  • Dive by Olivia Dean
  • Summertime by Ella Fitzgerald
  • Cry Me A River by Ella Fitzgerald

At this point, it’s really important to start questioning AI’s responses. For example, Valerie is already on the set list at Grade 1.

Questioning why specific recommendations are made is also important. For example, Cry Me A River was originally a hit for Julie London and was featured on the 2012 Grade 4 Vocals set list, but the later Ella Fitzgerald version is more embellished with syncopated rhythms and ad libs. The distinction between these two versions may be the difference between whether or not this song would meet the requirements for this grade:

‘One caveat: for an own-choice song, the specific arrangement you perform matters enormously. A song can become much more suitable for Grade 5 if the backing and vocal arrangement deliberately create an 8-bar improvisation section, introduce appropriate vocal embellishments, or expose rhythmic/melodic material that isn't prominent in the original.’

What skills do you want to showcase?

ChatGPT segued nicely into this of its own accord but making sure the skills being demonstrated in an own choice song play to candidate’s strengths is one of the option’s key benefits. At this point it is worth revisiting the parameters and perhaps selecting a few to showcase. In this example, we said I wanted to showcase the following:

  • Blues scales
  • Melisma
  • Improvisation.

Having taken Valerie out of the equation, ChatGPT came back with a slightly revised list of five songs, each with a rating out of five in for each of those three musical features:

  Blues scale Melisma 8-bar improvisation
Summertime by Ella Fitzgerald 5 stars 5 stars 5 stars
Cry Me a River by Ella Fitzgerald 4.5 stars 5 stars 5 stars
Back to Black by Amy Winehouse 4 stars 4 stars 4.5 stars
Dive by Olivia Dean 4 stars 4 stars 4 stars
Escapism by RAYE 3.5 stars 4.5 stars 4.5 stars

If we take this at face value, Summertime is the winner with Cry Me a River a close second.

But did it work?

It was a mixed bag. Based on the recordings found on Spotify, two Ella Fitzgerald tracks would meet the parameters for Grade 5. Ella’s renditions of these songs have a wider range than some others, larger interval jumps and contains melisma. However, Back to Black, Dive and Escapism were less convincing suggestions.

Firstly, we need to highlight that both Back to Black and Escapism contain adult language and content. While this is not strictly forbidden within the context of our exams, it is advisable to consider whether it is appropriate, both in terms of the candidate performing the song, and the impact it may have on their audience/examiner.

Back to Black was an odd choice for ChatGPT to make and it may be that it was basing it on a specific live recording rather than the single or album track; checking which source AI is basing their suggestions on is therefore highly recommended. Even if this were the case though, the range is only around an octave with lots of repeated notes meaning there is limited demand on the vocal agility of the singer for this level of exam.

Similar feedback about range could be said of Dive, although there is more scope for ad libs that could incorporate melisma and increase the range, particularly in the bridge section.

Escapism, again, has a mostly narrow vocal range (including some rapping) and is somewhat repetitive. The song itself is focused on the production rather than the vocalist, and so isn’t a great recommendation for showcasing the singer’s ability.

Final thoughts

AI can be a useful starting point for exploring repertoire, but it should not decide whether a song is suitable for an exam - that judgement remains with the candidate, teacher and Trinity College London, and done so using the current syllabus, the specific score or recording, and the candidate’s proposed arrangement. An AI recommendation is therefore an idea to investigate, not evidence that the assessment requirements have been met.

If you do choose to use AI to find suggested songs, some points to consider are:

  • What AI is basing its recommendations on. Is it a score or a recording? If so, which one?
  • If it is based on a recording, is notation available that would reflect this version?
  • Can the recommended songs be found on the song lists for any of the other grades? If so, can a performance of it be elevated to sufficiently meet the technical and musical demands outlined in the parameters or should it be disregarded?
  • How does the song compare with those set by Trinity College London in the published graded songbook for that grade?
  • Are the songs’ lyrical content appropriate for the singer?

Would you like further guidance on selecting own choice songs for Trinity Rock & Pop exams? Why not check out our previous blog: Make it yours: choosing an own choice song for a Trinity Rock & Pop exam.

Sign up to receive emails from Trinity College London

Sign up for emails
Comments & Replies

Related posts